Friday, January 25, 2008

I have now decided that I am incredibly tired of Greek literature if you can even call it that. The Greeks were certainly interesting folks, but they wrote in a way so affected by their pagan ways that all of the writings of fiction came out to be almost exactly the same. There is a hero. There is a problem. Someone asks the oracle or Gods for help. The answer isn’t what everyone wants to hear. No one listens and then some stuff goes down. I found this interesting the first few times, although after freshman English, three years of Latin filled with numerous Greek and Roman stories, and finally this version of Oedipus I have had my fill.

In comparison to writings inspired by other religions such as Christianity and Judaism the stories of the Greeks are rather meaningless and devoid of moral value. I find that most of the Greek stories, unless retold by Disney, end up creating little connection at all between the readers, and the characters and gods who are unlikable, unrealistic, and lack the power to make their own decisions.

Oedipus I found to be interesting in 9th grade because I was a 9th grader. Now that I read it again in a form that I like even less I find very little to enjoy. Maybe as it is a tragedy there is not supposed to be any joy created. Instead all I get from the play is that Oedipus has many unfortunate things happen to him for no reason. I don’t even like him, but there is almost no one who deserves what he goes through or even to hear about it. Is the whole story just meant to show that destiny can’t be stopped, again, and that not only must Oedipus’s father be punished with death, but also his son and mother and many others must be punished to make up for one betrayal of the gods? The whole plot is unnecessary and recycled. The incest is just a tabloid headline like topic to pull in readers.

The only thing I see in a story such as this is brainwashing provided to the people to let them know what will happen if they don’t listen to what their leaders told their gods to tell their priests to tell them. This controlling probably worked do to the empty mindedness of most of the Greeks and the vulnerability to fear of all humans ever. Fear would keep the people docile. Fear would keep the poor, poor. Fear destroys governments and brings them about. I don’t see anything good about fear, but I also don’t have to lose what every leader always has, being one over all.

15 comments:

Navdeep Khera said...

Eric Lewis--

It is nice to see a different approach to this story. You have had your fair share of mythology and have summed it up quite well. I agree with you in why I don't know why Oedipus is forced to endure such a tragic fate which as you noted also affects the rest of his family. I like your little rant about fear though, and it is something I have not heard of yet. You raise some great issues about how fear can be a powerful tool to keep those in power remain in power.

Navdeep

Julia Ivanova said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Julia Ivanova said...

Eric,
I really enjoyed reading this; actually I was laughing quite hard--mainly because everything you say is rather true. It is annoying that these stories have absolutly no moral purpose, and are targeted to keep people in constant fear. The idea that fate is inescapeable is a bit ridiculous when see some poor bloke blinding himself over things he had no control over whatsoever. The last paragraph was my favorite though: it is applicable to our lives today as well. Thank you for that refreshing piece of blogging!
The Bulgarian

Julia Ivanova said...

p.s. obviously Bulgarians are technologically retarded as well because I just deleted my first comment by accident

lemanley said...

nice pessimistic view of the novel, i really enjoyed reading your blog and getting a feeling of fear. i would have to disagree on this novel being useless. Although many of us have had our fair share of Greek, i see it important to take every story as if it were your first. Then make your opinion. But when you start off on a negative note, there really is nothing you can get out of it, but what you want. the portion about fear, is quite true, it has worked for many kingdoms in the past, how else would someone stay in order?? Not many nice kings have made it far before being assasinated. thanks for the different POV-lemanley

warren wagoner said...

Mr. Lewis,
Very interesting blog post. I like your view point on mythology and how it has become jaded over the years. Sometimes I also feel your pain since all of the stories seem very similar and a lot of the same material is recycled.

warren wagoner said...

Mr. Lewis,
Very interesting blog post. I like your view point on mythology and how it has become jaded over the years. Sometimes I also feel your pain since all of the stories seem very similar and a lot of the same material is recycled.

Quinn de la Concepcion said...

I never thought of the story in this way, but I found what you said to be true. I definitely agree that no person should be put what Oedipus wen through. I don't believe that he deserved what he got. I never really noticed the pattern in Greek mythology, but now that I have read your blog, I do. Awesome job pointing out the reason that these stories were created. Good job!

Lauren Motzkin said...

Wow, Eric. Wow. Too true. I liked Oedipus a little bit more than you did but you make some really legit points.
1. Greek mythology is all similar. I never really thought about it but after you pointed it out it's kind of obvious.
2. I also didn't like Oedipus. Sure, I felt a little bad for him, but when he gouges his eyes out and exiles himself at the end of the play I thought, "ya well that's what you get for sleeping with your mom, creeper."

Nice original blog!
Lauren

Gary Simpson said...

Hey Eric, how's it going. Good blog. I like rants and tirades (although not as much as diatribes). We already had qick slam session on Greek literature in class, so you know that I agree. I didn't mind the Iliad (but that was about war, so I was bound to like it) but all that other Greek crap is pretty repetitive. The Greeks' biggest contribution to society were almost exclusively secular or scientific in nature. So the "fear the gods" stuff is completely pointless. Look what happened to Leonidas. Screw the gods. Unless Zeus actually alights from Olympus and shoves a lightning bolt..you get the point.

Andrew Grady said...

Eric,

This is a beautiful pessimistic approach to the Oedipus story and I LIKE it mucho. Usually every body writes lies and/or interpretations about the stories we read in order to complete the assignment. You have definitely not fallen in with that crowd and it makes me happy that you actually express your true opinions--there are no sugar-coated toppings here. Not everybody can like all the stories we have read and I am glad that someone has manned/womanned up. Thank you for the blog.

LCC said...

Eric--it's fine to write a good "this particular classic doesn't deserve it's reputation" rant, even fun I suspect, but it's a school assignment after all, so please watch the language.

Also, remember you still owe a China blog.

rebecca_crane said...

beautiful Eric. You truely captured what Greek litterature truely is... haha I was laughing so hard reading this, but I do agree with your points. I have had some problems myself trying to sympathise with these characters, just kind of feeling,"oh well that sucks for you"

Dave said...

EL-
Well, this was interesting. It seems clear enough for me to draw the following conclusion: you dislike Greet literature.
I find myself unable to agree with you, as Greek literature has often been a source of inspiration and council for me, but to each his own.

LCC said...

Thanks for the updated version.